IP Service

IP Members

Service Usage and Satisfaction

For IP member questionnaires, IP registrars and Non-IP registrars users were invited to fill in the questionnaires by e-mail invitation only, with 21 valid questionnaires collected. The first question asked members on their intended use for IP applications. It was divided into "Non-IP registrar" who "apply for their own use" and "IP registrar" who "apply for IP and distribute it to other companies/units for use", and the ratio of the two was 7 to 3. The majority of the respondents in this survey were "Non-IP registrars."

Most of the services of TWNIC were positively evaluated, respondents who chose "satisfied" or "very satisfied" indicated 100% satisfaction with "participation in TWNIC seminars," "connection bandwidth survey," "participation in TWNIC education and training", "contacting customer service by phone or e-mail", "global IP address and AS number statistics," "reading TWNIC’s Annual Report and e-newsletter", "browsing TWNIC’s website and blog", and "following TWNIC’s social media posts". The "RPKI Management System/RPKI Validator Website" and "RMS Resource Management System" had the highest usage rates, and each had a 90% satisfaction rate. The satisfaction rate of "ISP annual authentication website" and "IP address/ASN issuance and Second Opinion audit" were both above 80%. The satisfaction rate of "IP member registration/IP membership application website" was only 66.7%, while the remaining 33.3% of respondents all indicated "average" satisfaction.

n= Satisfied Very Satisfied
Used the RPKI management system/RPKI Validator website 12 50.0% 41.7%
Used the RMS resource management system 11 54.5% 36.4%
Attended TWNIC conferences 9 33.3% 66.7%
Statistics of Internet Connection Bandwidth 8 62.5% 37.5%
Participated in TWNIC training courses 7 28.6 71.4%
Contacted customer service via email, phone 7 57.1% 42.9%
Global IP address and AS number statistics 7 71.4% 28.6%
ISP yearbook website 6 66.7% 16.7%
IP address/ASN allocation, second opinion audit 6 66.7% 16.7%
Read the TWNIC annual report, e-newsletter 5 40.0% 60.0%
IP membership registration/IP membership request website 3 33.3% 33.3%
Browsed the official website or blog 2 100% 0%
Followed official social media 1 100% 0%

Source: Online Survey (2021)

Evaluation of the Overall Satisfaction and Value Perceptions

The overall satisfaction rate of IP members on TWNIC falls into the average and positive categories. The satisfaction rate for "IP Distribution Service" was 81.0%. The satisfaction rate of "service quality" was also 81.0%. The satisfaction rate of "technical support" was 76.2%, more than the other two indicators.

Last year, the satisfaction rate of technical support was 80.7%, but this year, it dropped by 4.5%, with a satisfaction rate of only 76.2%. The satisfaction rate of technical support has been decreasing over the years, and the percentage of those who chose "average" has been increasing every year. The satisfaction rate of IP distribution service this year is 81.0%, down 10% from the previous year. The percentage of those who chose "average" this year also grew most significantly, while the percentage of those who chose "very good" this year was the highest. The satisfaction rate of IP distribution service this year is 81.0%, down 10% from the previous year. The percentage of those who chose "average" this year also grew most significantly, while the percentage of those who chose "very good" this year was the highest.

Service Quality

Technical Support

IP Address Allocation

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Service Quality

Technical Support

IP Address Allocation

n=57
Source: Online Survey (2020)

Service Quality

Technical Support

IP Address Allocation

n=40
Source: Online Survey (2019)

Both trust and value perception indicators performed better than overall satisfaction. More than half of the respondents chose "very good", with a trustworthiness level of 85.7%, and the value of the service was even as high as 90%. The trustworthiness level has dropped by 9.0% this year, with 85.7% compared to previous years. The trustworthiness level has gradually declined, and the proportion of those who chose "average" this year was significantly higher than previous years' surveys.

The value perception level is 90.5%, down 4.3% compared to last year, and the percentage of people choosing "average" this year was also slightly higher than last year.

Trust to TWNIC

Value of TWNIC Service

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Trust to TWNIC

Value of TWNIC Service

n=57
Source: Online Survey (2020)

Trust to TWNIC

Value of TWNIC Service

n=40
Source: Online Survey (2019)

Value of TWNIC Service

According to the evaluation of IP members' perception of the value of each registrar service, "IP member registration/IP member application website" and "IP address/ASN issuance, Second Opinion audit" had the highest perception of service value, with 90% for both indicators. The value of the "RMS" service was 80%. The value of "RPKI Management System/RPKI Validator Website" was 76.2%, and the value of "Global IP Address and ASN Statistics" was 71.4%, with the highest percentage of "very valuable" among all indicators.

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Support and Service

In the face of IPv4 scarcity, the highest percentage of IP members want the center to "help release unused IPv4 addresses" (61.9%). The percentages of "recovering or restoring unused IPv4 addresses" and "sharing ways to transfer related resources" were both over 50%, respectively.

n=33
Source: Online Survey (2021)

80% of IP members believe that IPv6 deployment requires assistance from TWNIC. The highest percentage was "promoting IPv6 to hardware, software and content providers" at 61.9%, while the percentage of "sharing successful IPv6 deployment cases for reference" and "providing IPv6 education and training" were both 52.4%. "Knowledge sharing among member organizations on IPv6 deployment experience" accounted for over 40%.

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Information Services

More than 60% of IP members usually received information on IP topics through "official websites", more than 40% through "search engines" and "e-newspapers", and 30% through "news websites". Twenty percent of the IP members usually get information through "friends, family and colleagues" and "blogs". Sixty percent of the IP members preferred to get information related to the center through "official websites", 50% preferred to get it through "e-newsletters", about 15% preferred to get it through "Facebook fan groups", and 10% preferred to get it through "YouTube."

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Impact of COVID-19

95.2% of IP members using the service in the past three months were not affected. During the epidemic period in the past three months, 50% of IP members said that the service condition had not changed and 30% thought that the service had improved.

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

Expectations and Recommendations

IP members indicated that they hope TWNIC can organize more activities in the future, such as education training and seminars. They also hoped that the service could be digitized and operated online, and that more assistance can be provided to deal with the IPv4 scarcity problem.

Anticipated content Responses
RMS can do better 1
More education training can be provided based on actual needs 1
It is recommended to create an online system to change the route object and other related information directly without manual processing via e-mail. The questionnaire can be filled in by adding the options that were changed before the previous page. 1
Development and cultivation (of clients) 1
Release more IPv4 1
None 15

n=21
Source: Online Survey (2021)

IP Registrar

In this year's survey for IP members, in addition to the existing online quantitative survey, we added one on one in-depth interviews with IP address allocation agencies and interviewed two respondents.

Services have been fully digitized, and thus business interactions are safe from COVID-19 impact

As TWNIC's online services and interaction mechanism are in full operation, business interactions and communications between the two parties went smoothly and suffered no impact from COVID-19 even if both sides started working remotely. In addition, stakeholders also think the online events/training sessions went very well. They are quite satisfied with their interactions with TWNIC in general.

We interact with TWNIC mainly on the phone and via email, so there was no problem with communications. Most of the seminars and conferences have gone online, so there wasn't much effect. So far it looks like COVID-19 has no impact on our interactions with TWNIC.

A lot of services have been digitized before the COVID-19 outbreak, so we can handle the majority of issues with what's available on the TWNIC website. We rarely met each other in person these two years because of COVID-19. Now that the training sessions have gone online, I think everything is fine.

Enhance system stability and user friendliness, assist in troubleshooting and follow-ups

Based on their user experience, stakeholders remind TWNIC to watch out for data/system maintenance and stability and wish to have a friendlier UI. They also mentioned their current IP interface system is maintained by an outsourced service provider, so they are not able to reach the tech person immediately whenever there's a problem. Therefore, they hope TWNIC can help them with troubleshooting and issue tracking.

So far everything's ok, but we should pay more attention to maintenance and update. System stability is still our main concern because we want to avoid data inconsistency. As to minor issues, we wonder if an inquiry screen can be made available or if the UI can be more user-friendly.

We hope TWNIC to set up a specific point of contact to help us track issues with the outsourced service provider. Since this interface was built by TWNIC's outsourced partner, we hope TWNIC can help us do the follow-ups when we raise issues.

The necessity and incentive to expedite IPv6 adoption in Internet industry

Stakeholders have mentioned that TWNIC needs to promote IPv6 adoption more actively to increase its necessity; for example, urging content businesses to switch their websites to IPv6 and setting IPv6 as default on equipment related to IoT application. They also expect TWNIC to assist in the widespread IPv6 adoption by providing the industries with incentives such as rent/tax deduction to expedite the implementation.

For potential adopters in IoT businesses, it would be helpful if TWNIC initiates the communication by suggesting prioritizing v6 over v4 to accelerate the widespread adoption of v6.

As to IPv6 compatible devices, it would be great to take into account the government's special subsidies so that rent/tax reduction can serve as an incentive for device vendors and users to speed up their v6 adoption.

Promote awareness on security issues derived from the services, assist the industry in strengthening their cyber defense

When asked about suggestions to the services, stakeholders said TWNIC can incorporate TWCERT/CC services in theirs and focus more on providing security training on issues associated with IP. As to the current security requirements of IP address allocation agencies, they hope the planned pace can be adjusted and allow businesses to achieve the recommended requirements in their own pace.

For now, it appears a lot of issues occur on users’ side. For example, a regular user might be used as a springboard because s/he uses an IP camera or has virus on the computer. I believe the security problem can be addressed more efficiently if TWNIC can promote the security awareness or provide a certain solutions.

Insightful and helpful event topics/content, looking forward to timely updates and explaining complicated subject matters in simple terms

In terms of information provision, stakeholders have approved what's been delivered in training courses, activities and publications. They also look forward to insight sharing about network trends and technologies as well as timely-updated website with the latest topics, tech info made simple with easy-to-understand explanation to reach a larger audience.

I like the topics and discussion in training courses and seminars and maybe there can be more info on latest issues, new technologies and how RPKI evolves.

They have a lot of materials which tech people can easily understand, but for the general public, it would be better to translate down the subject matters with easy-to-understand description.

Bring the cross-field synergy of social media into play

TWNIC and TWCERT/CC are running their social media accounts separately, but they should put emphasis on the relevance of their services and create synergistic effect strategically. Through different content/service users, they can expand their influence to other social media and bring the collaborative benefits into play.

The content is information-rich, which is good. However, it looks like there are many websites and Facebook pages related to TWNIC, such as "domain name friends" and TWCERT/CC. I suggest making use of the relevance despite the differences... Whenever TWNIC publishes a post about cyber-security, they should make sure users can be directed to TWCERT/CC even if it's a shared/forwarded post. It is also important to share each other's post.

Copyright© Taiwan Network Information Center